Home/Categories/Most Rewatchable Scene

Most Rewatchable Scene

Hosts identify scenes they rewatch or would stop on when channel surfing.

Most Rewatchable Scene has run in 428 episodes. The most recent 40 are listed below — open any episode at its timestamp to hear the segment.

⌕

‘Pacific Heights’Bill Simmons

The scene where Carter Hayes talks his way through the rental application, working the 'idiot' Drake Goodman and the smart girl with rapid-fire lies (private trust, bank in San Antonio, etc.)

‘Pacific Heights’Bill Simmons

The scene where Drake Goodman calls Mr. Baker (the prospective Black tenant) 'one of those minority scam artists' — calls it his favorite scene because it turns you against Drake Goodman

‘Pacific Heights’Bill Simmons

The scene where Carter somehow gets into the house/apartment after being let in and changes the locks

‘Pacific Heights’Chris Ryan

Engages heavily with the rental application scene and the 'Carter gets into the place' scene but doesn't stake out one singular independent pick, mostly riffing on Bill's picks (Drake Goodman lines, the lease scam)

‘Pacific Heights’Kyle Brandt

The opening scene of the movie where Mrs. Griswold (Christie Brinkley-like character) is lying around naked/getting a suntan minutes into the film

‘The Good Son’Bill Simmons

The 10-car pileup/highway accident scene caused by Henry ('Once you realize you can do anything, you're free') - he calls it 'probably my most rewatchable' - though he also walks through a chain of scenes including the treehouse, rock-throwing, Rottweiler standoff, killing the dog and dumping it in the well, and the ice skating scene.

‘The Good Son’Chris Ryan

Engages with the treehouse scene (relates it to childhood unsupervised play) and the highway pileup aftermath, but doesn't state one definitive standalone pick, mostly reacting to Bill's choices.

‘The Good Son’Sean Fennessey

Highlights the treehouse/well scene ('slow walks you... but by the time they're smoking a cigarette and firing the arrow') and the skating scene with Connie underwater, but doesn't commit to one definitive single pick, discussing multiple scenes alongside Bill.

‘Domestic Disturbance’Bill Simmons

The baseball catch scene between Danny and Rick - calls it his favorite scene and the most rewatchable, though he wishes there were more scenes like it

‘The Hand That Rocks the Cradle’Bill Simmons

The creepy Dr. Mott gynecological exam scene where he sends the nurse out and starts massaging her stomach; also names the Peyton meets Claire and Solomon interview scene, the 3 a.m. breastfeeding/nanny scene, and the park scene where the old woman tells Peyton her baby has her eyes / Peyton messing with the little kid Joey

‘The Hand That Rocks the Cradle’Chris Ryan

Agrees with the Dr. Mott exam scene, especially him sending the nurse out ('why don't you give him the news, I got this'); also highlights the double-date smoking scene and Peyton at the park checking on the kid

‘The Hand That Rocks the Cradle’Joanna Robinson

Discusses and endorses the Dr. Mott exam scene as realistic/creepy but doesn't clearly name her own separate top pick; participates in discussion of the smoking/double-date scene and park scene without a distinct definitive choice

Episode	Host	Answer
‘Pacific Heights’	Bill Simmons	The scene where Carter Hayes talks his way through the rental application, working the 'idiot' Drake Goodman and the smart girl with rapid-fire lies (private trust, bank in San Antonio, etc.)
‘Pacific Heights’	Bill Simmons	The scene where Drake Goodman calls Mr. Baker (the prospective Black tenant) 'one of those minority scam artists' — calls it his favorite scene because it turns you against Drake Goodman
‘Pacific Heights’	Bill Simmons	The scene where Carter somehow gets into the house/apartment after being let in and changes the locks
‘Pacific Heights’	Chris Ryan	Engages heavily with the rental application scene and the 'Carter gets into the place' scene but doesn't stake out one singular independent pick, mostly riffing on Bill's picks (Drake Goodman lines, the lease scam)
‘Pacific Heights’	Kyle Brandt	The opening scene of the movie where Mrs. Griswold (Christie Brinkley-like character) is lying around naked/getting a suntan minutes into the film
‘The Good Son’	Bill Simmons	The 10-car pileup/highway accident scene caused by Henry ('Once you realize you can do anything, you're free') - he calls it 'probably my most rewatchable' - though he also walks through a chain of scenes including the treehouse, rock-throwing, Rottweiler standoff, killing the dog and dumping it in the well, and the ice skating scene.
‘The Good Son’	Chris Ryan	Engages with the treehouse scene (relates it to childhood unsupervised play) and the highway pileup aftermath, but doesn't state one definitive standalone pick, mostly reacting to Bill's choices.
‘The Good Son’	Sean Fennessey	Highlights the treehouse/well scene ('slow walks you... but by the time they're smoking a cigarette and firing the arrow') and the skating scene with Connie underwater, but doesn't commit to one definitive single pick, discussing multiple scenes alongside Bill.
‘Domestic Disturbance’	Bill Simmons	The baseball catch scene between Danny and Rick - calls it his favorite scene and the most rewatchable, though he wishes there were more scenes like it
‘The Hand That Rocks the Cradle’	Bill Simmons	The creepy Dr. Mott gynecological exam scene where he sends the nurse out and starts massaging her stomach; also names the Peyton meets Claire and Solomon interview scene, the 3 a.m. breastfeeding/nanny scene, and the park scene where the old woman tells Peyton her baby has her eyes / Peyton messing with the little kid Joey
‘The Hand That Rocks the Cradle’	Chris Ryan	Agrees with the Dr. Mott exam scene, especially him sending the nurse out ('why don't you give him the news, I got this'); also highlights the double-date smoking scene and Peyton at the park checking on the kid
‘The Hand That Rocks the Cradle’	Joanna Robinson	Discusses and endorses the Dr. Mott exam scene as realistic/creepy but doesn't clearly name her own separate top pick; participates in discussion of the smoking/double-date scene and park scene without a distinct definitive choice